When choosing bathtubs, the comparison often comes down to cast-iron tubs versus Americast tubs.
Cast-iron tubs are heavy, durable, and have a porcelain enamel finish. They keep bath water warm for a long time.
Americast tubs, created by American Standard, are similar in durability but much lighter, making them easier to install. They are made using a bonded material process.
Deciding between the two involves considering installation difficulty, maintenance, appearance, heat retention, and cost. Each factor is crucial in deciding the best bathtub for a bathroom.
Durability and Maintenance
When evaluating durability and maintenance, it's important to consider the long-lasting nature of cast iron tubs versus the lighter Americast options.
Cast iron tubs are known for their durability, with the ability to resist scratches and handle heavy weight and impacts, thanks to their enamel coating that prevents chipping. These tubs are often chosen for their lasting quality and classic appeal.
The porcelain finish on cast iron tubs is aesthetically pleasing and easy to clean, as its non-porous surface prevents bacteria growth. However, the heavy weight of cast iron requires a strong support structure and can make installation more challenging.
Americast tubs, on the other hand, offer a contemporary option that combines a porcelain finish with steel and a composite backing, resulting in a lighter tub that is easier to install. They maintain heat well and, while not as indestructible as cast iron, are still durable.
Americast tubs meet the needs of homeowners who value easy installation and maintenance without completely compromising on toughness.
Installation and Weight
Cast-iron bathtubs require a strong support structure because of their heavy weight. The weight and installation of a bathtub are important considerations for both the initial setup and the long-term integrity of the bathroom structure.
Americast tubs are made from a composite material that combines the durability of steel with less weight, which makes them easier to transport and install. While cast-iron tubs can weigh several hundred pounds, Americast tubs are lighter, requiring less labor and fewer people for installation. This can lead to cost savings as the lighter weight also eliminates the need for additional floor reinforcement that cast-iron tubs often require.
For homeowners and contractors, choosing Americast tubs can mean lower installation costs. Cast-iron tubs typically require professional installation, but the lighter Americast tubs are easier to handle. They can be installed using a mortar bed for stability or with specific accessories, offering flexibility for different bathroom layouts.
Design and Aesthetics
Cast-iron and Americast tubs offer different design choices.
Cast-iron tubs are durable with a vintage aesthetic, often associated with a traditional bathroom look. They come in various colors, including bold ones like black or red, which can add a modern touch. However, their design typically favors a classic style.
Americast tubs resemble cast-iron in durability but usually feature neutral colors such as white or beige. Their design is more modern and minimalist, easily fitting into various bathroom styles without making a bold statement.
Heat Retention and Comfort
Cast-iron tubs are known for effective heat transfer, keeping bath water warm for extended periods, which is beneficial for long soaks. Americast tubs, created by American Standard, are designed to retain heat potentially better than cast-iron due to their layered material construction that traps heat.
Both tub types are made for comfort, with their heat retention being a key factor for a comfortable bath, reducing the need to add hot water frequently.
Cost and Longevity
Cost and longevity are important factors when selecting a bathtub. Americast tubs are less expensive upfront, making them attractive for those on a budget. They provide a balance of quality and affordability.
Cast-iron tubs cost more initially but are highly durable, often lasting longer, which may lead to cost savings over time. They resist wear well, making them suitable for frequent use.
Some concerns exist about the durability of Americast tubs, which may not be as long-lasting as cast-iron options. It's important to consider both the purchase price and the expected lifespan when making a decision.
